Phone or Portal: How Patients Actually Reach a Practice

Portals and online booking keep growing, yet the most common reason patients skip the portal is wanting to talk to a person. Here is what the surveys show, and the one number nobody has measured.

  • Muhammad Qasim Hammad
  • 10 min read

Key takeaways

Key takeaways

  • + About 65% of US adults opened a patient portal in 2024, but that measures access, not whether patients prefer it to calling you.
  • + The most common reasons people skip the portal are wanting to speak to a provider directly and seeing no need.
  • + Older adults are online, with 90% of those 65 and older using the internet, yet far fewer use it to contact a doctor's office.
  • + In an MGMA poll, 71% of practices said fewer than a quarter of their patients self-schedule online.
  • + No primary source gives a phone versus online booking split, so count your own channel mix before reducing phone coverage.

Your practice has a portal, an online booking link and a phone number. The easy assumption is that the first two are slowly absorbing the third. The national numbers say that is only half true.

Launch day: the phones go quiet.

Hi, I'd ratherjust talk tosomeone.

Monday, 8:02 a.m.

Nobody counted the calls.

The portal launches. The phones are not asked.

Your practice may well run three ways in: a phone number, a patient portal and an online booking link. It is tempting to assume the second and third are steadily absorbing the first. Vendors say so often, and the portal numbers do look impressive. The harder question is who still picks up the phone, and whether you would notice if they could no longer reach you.

This post pulls together what US government surveys, a peer-reviewed study and two professional polls say about how patients reach a practice. It also says plainly what nobody has measured. It is a general overview for owners and office managers of US practices, not legal advice.

Is the portal replacing the phone?

Not on the evidence available. About two-thirds of US adults opened a patient portal in the past year, which is a large change from a decade ago. That still leaves roughly a third who did not, and no national data shows phone volume shrinking in step. Portal growth and phone demand are two separate questions.

The Office of the National Coordinator for Health IT (ONC) tracks this through the Health Information National Trends Survey. In 2024, more than 3 in 4 people said a provider or insurer had offered them online access to their records. And 65% had opened a portal at least once in the past year, up from 25% in 2014 [1].

The growth is real. But the number counts access, not habit: one login in twelve months qualifies, and it says nothing about how that person books a visit, asks a question or reschedules.

The same brief found that 89% of people who were offered a portal said their provider encouraged them to use it, and that those who were encouraged used it at higher rates than those who were not [1]. So portal use responds to what a practice does.

A portal login tells you a patient has access. It does not tell you how that patient wants to reach you.

Patient portal use in the US
65%
Offered and accessed a portal in 2024
ONC, HINTS 7
25%
Same measure in 2014
ONC, HINTS
89%
Of those offered said their provider encouraged use
ONC, 2024
Offered and accessed means the person opened a portal at least once in the past year.

Why do patients who skip the portal say they skip it?

The two most common reasons are a wish to deal with a person and a sense that they do not need it. Technology fear ranks lower. In national surveys, about 7 in 10 people who were offered a portal and did not use it said they would rather speak with their provider directly.

ONC's 2020 data brief, built on surveys from that year, reported that figure for people who were offered a portal but had not viewed it in the past year. About one-quarter cited privacy and security concerns, and about 20% said they were uncomfortable with computers. The brief adds that the top two reasons, preferring to speak to a provider and seeing no need, had held steady since 2017 [2].

A peer-reviewed analysis of the 2019 version of the survey, covering 4,815 adults, found the same ordering. Of those adults, 58.73% had not adopted a portal. Among the 2,828 non-adopters, 64.00% preferred in-person communication, 48.97% saw no need, 25.99% were uncomfortable with computers, 22.98% had no internet access and 21.00% had privacy concerns [3]. Older age was associated with preferring to speak to a provider, though the effect per year of age was small [3].

Two cautions apply. "Speak to my provider directly" could mean a phone call, a visit or a chat at the front desk, and the surveys do not separate those. And both sets of reasons predate 2024, so they describe why people stayed away while portals were still catching on, not necessarily why they do now. The 2024 ONC brief reported who used portals, not why the rest did not.

A preference for talking to someone does not vanish because the portal improves. Your phone line exists to serve it.

Are older patients offline?

No. Pew Research finds that 90% of adults 65 and older use the internet. The supportable description is narrower: many older patients are online but less likely to use the web to deal with a doctor's office. Calling them offline is wrong, and so is calling them portal-first.

Older adults: online, but a minority contact a doctor that way
90%
Adults 65 and older who use the internet
Pew, 2025
78%
Adults 65 and older who own a smartphone
Pew, 2025
24.3%
Adults 75 and older who used the internet to contact a doctor's office
NCHS, July to December 2022
Three different questions from three surveys. They measure access and one kind of contact, not phone use.

Pew's 2025 figures put internet use among adults 65 and older at 90%, up from 75% in 2021, and home broadband at 70% [5]. Smartphone ownership in that group is 78%, against 97% of adults 18 to 29, and 16% of adults 65 and older have a cellphone that is not a smartphone [6]. So the access is mostly there. The device in the pocket is less likely to be one that runs a portal app.

Being online is not the same as using the internet to reach a doctor. The National Health Interview Survey asked adults whether they had used the internet in the past 12 months to communicate with a doctor or doctor's office. The share was 41.5% at ages 18 to 29 and 47.7% at 30 to 44, then fell with each older group to 24.3% at 75 and older [4].

That does not show three in four people over 75 phone their doctor. They may visit, write, send a relative, or make no contact at all. It does show that for the oldest patients the internet is a minority channel for dealing with a practice, even though most of them are online.

How much online booking is actually happening?

Less than the marketing implies. In a July 2025 poll of medical practice leaders run by MGMA, 71% said fewer than a quarter of their patients use digital tools to self-schedule. Only 3% said more than three in four do. It is a poll of practices rather than patients, but it points away from a portal-first front desk.

The poll, MGMA Stat's July 29, 2025 survey, had 244 applicable responses. Beyond the 71%, 21% of practices said 25% to 50% of patients self-schedule, 5% said 51% to 75%, and 3% said more than 75% [7]. A similar poll in November 2024 found 73% in the lowest bracket, so the picture moved only slightly in eight months [7].

The question asks practices what share of their patients use self-scheduling, not whether the practice offers it. A practice can have a booking link and still sit in the lowest bracket.

A second MGMA poll, on December 9, 2025, asked leaders for their top patient access focus in 2026. No-shows led with 27%, followed by online scheduling at 24%, phone access at 22% and wait times at 21%, with 5% choosing something else. It drew 236 applicable responses [8]. Leaders are investing in online booking, and about one in five still names the phone as the first thing to fix.

In MGMA's poll, most practices said fewer than one patient in four books online.

Share of patients who self-schedule, as reported by practices
Under 25% of patients71%
25% to 50%21%
51% to 75%5%
More than 75%3%
Percent of practices in each bracket, from an MGMA Stat poll on July 29, 2025.

What has nobody measured?

The share of appointments booked by phone versus online. The research behind this post found no government or peer-reviewed figure for it. Industry surveys exist, but they come from companies that sell scheduling or intake tools, so this post does not quote them. Treat any specific split you read as one vendor's estimate.

We looked through federal health surveys and the peer-reviewed literature on online scheduling, and found no figure for how patients book. One peer-reviewed analysis of earlier National Health Interview Survey years found that adults 36 and older were significantly less likely than those 18 to 35 to schedule an appointment using the internet [9]. It gives no phone share either.

QuestionBest evidenceWhat it cannot tell you
How many adults use a portalONC, 2024: 65% opened one in the past yearHow they book or reach the practice
Why some do notONC 2020 and a 2019 peer-reviewed analysis: about 7 in 10 prefer to speak to a providerWhether that means phone or in person
Whether older adults are onlinePew, 2025: 90% of adults 65 and older use the internetHow they contact a doctor's office
How many patients self-scheduleMGMA poll, July 2025: 71% of practices under 25%Anything reported by patients themselves
Phone versus online bookingsNo primary figure foundAnything, so count your own

Every figure here is a national or sector average. Your own mix depends on your patients, your specialty and how easy your booking page is to find. A national average will not describe your front desk.

How do you measure your own channel mix?

Count every route a request takes for two weeks, then compare. Tally calls answered, missed and returned, online bookings, portal messages and walk-in requests. Your phone system, your booking tool's source report and a paper tally at the front desk cover most of it. That split is the only one that applies to your patients.

Start with the phone, because it is the easiest to undercount. Pull the call log and separate calls answered from calls that rang out or went to voicemail. If the second group is large, read voicemail is a queue nobody owns before drawing any conclusion about demand. A call nobody answered is not evidence that nobody called.

Then look at when the volume lands. Find your call volume peaks shows how to read the hourly pattern from the same log. Compare the hours your phone is busiest with the hours your online booking is busiest. If the two curves overlap, the channels are competing. If they do not, they are serving different moments, and cutting one will not push its patients into the other.

Finally, ask. Add one line to intake or to the first call: "How did you book this visit?" with four choices, phone, online, portal or in person. Record the answer for four weeks. Crude, yes. But you own the number, and it costs nothing.

Count these for two weeks
  • ✓Calls answered, and calls that rang out or went to voicemail
  • ✓Voicemails returned, and how long each took
  • ✓Busiest hours for the phone and for online booking
  • ✓Online bookings, with the time of day each was made
  • ✓Portal messages that were really requests for an appointment
  • ✓One intake question: how did you book this visit?
Every route a request can take to your front desk, written down before you change any coverage.

What should you do about phone coverage?

Do not cut phone coverage on the assumption the portal replaced it. The evidence supports keeping both: most practices report fewer than a quarter of patients self-scheduling, and the most common reason non-users give is wanting to speak to someone. Change coverage only after your own count shows the phone is quiet.

The risk runs one way. If you keep the phone staffed and the portal turns out to carry more than you thought, you lose some staff time. If you thin the phone and the surveys turn out to describe your patients, you lose the callers who wanted to talk, and they rarely tell you why they stopped. Closing for lunch is a small test. Dropping the afternoon is a big one.

You can also push in the other direction. ONC found that patients whose provider encouraged portal use were more likely to use it [1], so a sentence from the front desk, such as "you can also see this in the portal," costs nothing and may move some routine requests off the phone. That is a way to lighten the phone, as opposed to removing it.

If your count shows calls arriving when nobody can answer, you have three options: staff the hours, use a human answering service, or use an automated agent. Velaire Health is one version of the third, and we sell it, so weigh this paragraph accordingly. It answers calls on your existing number: after hours on the Recovery plan at $599 a month, with daytime overflow added on Growth at $1,199 and every inbound call on Pro from $1,999. It says it is automated at the start of every call, and a caller can ask for a person at any point. It checks live availability and books on the calendar Velaire keeps for your practice, confirming the time before the call ends. A caller with a clinical or urgent question is never booked and goes to your team. It does not write into your own calendar or record system, because those integrations are in development.

It also does nothing for your portal. Whether it earns its price depends on what your own two-week count shows about missed calls. Our post on checking your booking software fit covers what to ask any vendor about the calendar side.

Four lines of equal weight labeled phone, portal, website and in person, all running into one desk, with a gold dashed line across them where the count is taken.
Several routes lead to the same desk, and the mix between them is yours to count.
FAQs

Questions about this

No government or peer-reviewed source gives a national split, so no one can say for certain. An MGMA poll found 71% of practices have fewer than a quarter of patients self-scheduling, which suggests the phone still carries a large share. That figure is practice-reported. Count your own bookings for a few weeks.
In 2024, ONC's national survey found 65% of individuals had been offered and had accessed an online record or portal in the past year, up from 25% in 2014. More than 3 in 4 said they were offered access. Use means a login, not a preference for that channel over calling.
ONC's 2020 data brief found about 7 in 10 people who were offered a portal but did not use it preferred to speak with their provider directly. About one-quarter cited privacy or security, and about 20% were uncomfortable with computers. The top two reasons, wanting to speak to someone and seeing no need, had not changed since 2017.
No. Pew found 90% of adults 65 and older use the internet in 2025, and 78% own a smartphone. But in a federal health survey only 24.3% of adults 75 and older had used the internet to contact a doctor's office in the past year. Many are online and still phone-first.
Not before measuring. Most practices report fewer than a quarter of patients self-schedule, and the commonest reason for skipping the portal is wanting to speak to someone. Count calls answered, missed and returned, and online bookings, for two weeks. Cut or move coverage only if that count shows the phone is quiet.

Written by

Muhammad Qasim Hammad

Founder, Velaire Health

Builds AI front-office systems for medical and aesthetic practices. Posts here start from published sources rather than vendor claims, and every number links back to where it came from.

Keep reading

More from the journal.

Start here

What is an AI front office?

The plain-language explainer: what it does, what it deliberately doesn't, and how it compares with voicemail, an answering service, a phone tree, and hiring.

Read the guide
Let’s make room for better care

Your next caller
could be your next patient.

See how Velaire would handle the calls your practice misses. A personal walkthrough, built around your questions.

Let’s talk about your practice